Are Mystery Football Shirts Genuine?

Are Mystery Football Shirts Genuine?

Are Mystery Football Shirts Genuine?

Yes. Every Mystery Football Shirt supplied by My Mystery Shirt is 100% genuine and brand new with its original tags.

We know that authenticity is one of the biggest questions people have when buying a mystery football shirt online.

When you don't know exactly which shirt you're going to receive, you want to know that the surprise will be a genuine football shirt from an official club, league, country or manufacturer — not a counterfeit or unofficial product.

At My Mystery Shirt, 100% genuine shirts is one of the promises we make to our customers.

Are My Mystery Football Shirts Authentic?

Yes.

Every Mystery Football Shirt we supply is 100% authentic, brand new and supplied with its original tags.

We do not promote or sell counterfeit football shirts.

Our Mystery Football Shirt Boxes are designed to give you the excitement of discovering an unexpected shirt while knowing that the shirt itself is genuine.

Are Mystery Football Shirts Brand New?

Yes.

Every Mystery Football Shirt Box contains one brand-new genuine football shirt with its original tags.

Your shirt will come from the last five seasons, giving you the opportunity to discover shirts from a wide range of clubs, leagues and countries.

The mystery is the identity of the shirt — not its condition.

What Do My Mystery Shirt Customers Say?

Customer feedback is an important part of the My Mystery Shirt experience.

Our website has hundreds of 5-star customer reviews.

Customers regularly mention the quality of the shirts, fast delivery and the excitement of receiving something they wouldn't necessarily have chosen themselves.

Recent customer reviews include comments about receiving high-quality shirts, being impressed with the quality of their first Mystery Shirt, and enjoying discovering clubs and shirts they would not normally have selected themselves.

One verified customer described receiving a shirt as a great surprise and highlighted its excellent quality, while another praised the quality and said the shirt was not something they would have picked themselves.

We've also had customers return to order Mystery Shirts multiple times, including customers who receive a new shirt regularly as part of their collection.

Of course, customer reviews are individual experiences. That's why we make our own product promise clear:

100% genuine football shirts. Brand new. Original tags.

What Clubs and Leagues Can I Receive?

That's where the mystery comes in.

Our Mystery Football Shirt Boxes can contain genuine football shirts from any club, any league and any country, with shirts coming from the last five seasons.

This means you could receive a shirt from a club you already know and love, or you could discover a team, league or football culture you've never previously considered.

That's one of the reasons mystery shirts are so much fun.

Instead of searching for one specific shirt, you get the opportunity to discover something completely different.

Can I Choose Which Shirt I Receive?

No — you don't choose the exact shirt.

That's the main idea behind a Mystery Football Shirt Box.

However, the experience isn't completely random.

When ordering, you can choose your preferred size and tell us what would suit you best.

You can select from three mystery preferences:

Play It Safer

Prefer something you might recognise?

We'll lean towards more familiar clubs and countries.

Keep It A Mystery

The ultimate mystery.

Leave the choice completely up to us and see what arrives.

More Obscure

Fancy something different?

We'll look for a more unusual, lesser-known or hard-to-find football shirt.

You can also tell us about teams, leagues or colours you'd prefer to avoid, so we can take your preferences into consideration when selecting your shirt.

Can I Request a Specific Team?

The Mystery Football Shirt Box is designed around the surprise, so you cannot request a specific team or exact shirt.

If there is a particular club you absolutely want, our The Vault collection is the better option.

The Vault allows you to browse our collection of genuine football shirts and choose the exact team, shirt and size you want.

If you'd rather leave the choice to us and discover something unexpected, explore our Mystery Football Shirt Box range.

What Size Football Shirt Will I Receive?

You choose your size when ordering.

This means that although the exact shirt is a mystery, the size isn't.

Our Mystery Football Shirt Boxes have a range of sizes available, so you can choose the size you need when placing your order.

If you're unsure which size to choose, check our football shirt size guide before ordering.

Can I Avoid Certain Teams or Leagues?

Yes.

We understand that football fans can have strong preferences when it comes to clubs, leagues and colours.

That's why our Mystery Football Shirt Boxes allow you to tell us about teams, leagues or colours you'd prefer to avoid.

We'll take those preferences into consideration when selecting your shirt while keeping the final choice a mystery.

Can I Receive a Shirt I Already Own?

If you're ordering additional Mystery Football Shirt Boxes, we take your previous Mystery Shirt orders into consideration to help avoid sending you the same shirt again.

Our product information specifically states that there are no duplicate shirts when ordering additional Mystery Shirt Boxes from us.

This is particularly useful for collectors who order Mystery Shirts regularly.

Why Buy a Genuine Mystery Football Shirt?

Part of the appeal of a Mystery Football Shirt Box is discovering something you probably wouldn't have chosen yourself.

It's easy to buy a shirt from your favourite club.

But there are thousands of football clubs around the world, with different leagues, countries, designs and football cultures to discover.

A mystery shirt gives you the opportunity to add something completely different to your collection.

You might discover:

  • A club you've never heard of
  • A league you've never watched
  • A country you wouldn't normally consider
  • A shirt design you wouldn't have chosen yourself
  • A new favourite shirt for your collection

That's the idea behind My Mystery Shirt.

You know it's a football shirt. You just don't know which one.

What Makes My Mystery Shirt Different?

We're football fans and shirt collectors ourselves.

We've visited over 100 football stadiums across the UK and Europe, and our passion for football and football shirts is at the heart of what we do.

Our aim is to give football fans a trustworthy and enjoyably mysterious experience — helping you discover clubs, leagues and shirts you may never have considered before.

That's why authenticity is so important to us.

We don't want the mystery to come at the expense of quality.

Our Authenticity Promise

When you order a Mystery Football Shirt Box from My Mystery Shirt, you can expect:

  • 100% genuine football shirt
  • Brand new
  • Original tags
  • From the last five seasons
  • Any club, league or country
  • Your chosen size
  • Your selected mystery preference
  • Teams, leagues and colours you want to avoid taken into consideration
  • No duplicate shirts when ordering additional Mystery Shirt Boxes

These are the things you know before you open the box.

The only thing you don't know is which genuine football shirt is inside.

Learn More About Mystery Football Shirts

Want to understand mystery football shirts in more detail? Read what a mystery football shirt box is and how Mystery Football Shirt Boxes work.

Ready to Discover Your Next Shirt?

If you're looking for a genuine football shirt but want to make the experience more exciting, explore our Mystery Football Shirt Box range.

Choose your size, select how much mystery you want, tell us what you'd prefer to avoid — and we'll take care of the rest.

You provide the preferences. We provide the mystery.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.