Honestly - unbelievable. The away shirt of a CONIFA team that have only played 8 games EVER? As a lover of obscure football shirts, this is the absolute dream. No idea how you've even got hold of this beauty to send it out! Thank you so much! Tom
Men's Mystery Football Shirt Box
Love football shirts? Love surprises? Our men's mystery football shirt combines both, giving you the chance to discover a genuine football shirt you might never have chosen for yourself.
Inside every box is 1 genuine, brand-new football shirt with tags, from ANY club, ANY league and ANY country. Your shirt will be from the last 5 seasons, giving you the chance to discover everything from a familiar football favourite to a more unusual club you've never come across before.
How does the mystery work?
The best part is that you can choose how much mystery you want.
PLAY IT SAFER
Prefer something you might recognise? We'll lean towards more familiar clubs and countries.
KEEP IT A MYSTERY
The ultimate mystery! Leave it completely up to us and see what arrives.
MORE OBSCURE
Fancy something different? We'll look for a more unusual, lesser-known or hard-to-find shirt.
You can also tell us which teams, leagues or colours you'd prefer to avoid, so we can take your preferences into consideration when choosing your shirt.
What's included?
- 1 genuine men's football shirt
- Brand new with original tags
- From the last 5 seasons
- A shirt from ANY club, ANY league and ANY country
- Your chosen shirt size
- Your selected mystery preference
- Your requested teams, leagues or colours to avoid taken into consideration
- No duplicate shirts when ordering additional Mystery Shirt Boxes from us
Every shirt is 100% authentic. No replicas and no counterfeit shirts — just a genuine football shirt ready to become part of your collection.
More than just a football shirt
Whether you're building a football shirt collection, looking for something completely different to wear, or searching for an exciting gift for a football fan, the Mystery Football Shirt Box makes every delivery an opportunity to discover something new.
You could receive a shirt from a club you've supported for years, a team you've never heard of, or a country you wouldn't normally think to collect. That's the fun of the mystery.
And because you can choose your preferred level of mystery and tell us what you'd rather avoid, it's not simply a completely random shirt — the mystery is yours to control.
Prefer to choose your own shirt?
If you'd rather know exactly what you're getting, take a look at our football shirts collection in The Vault, where you can choose from our available genuine shirts.
Looking for a mystery shirt for someone else? We also offer a Kid's Mystery Football Shirt Box, Women's Mystery Football Shirt Box and Mystery Scarf Box.
Ready to discover your next shirt?
Choose your size, select how much mystery you want, tell us anything you'd prefer to avoid, and let us take care of the rest.
You know it's a football shirt. You just don't know which one.
Order your Men's Mystery Football Shirt Box today and discover a genuine football shirt from somewhere around the world.
Customer Reviews
Overall rating: 5.0 / 5 from 221 reviews.
This was a Fantasy Football prize, we have used My Mystery Shirt for prizes in the past. The level of service and responsiveness are brillant and the shirts themselves are of great quality.
My shirt is AWESOME. Better than I could have guessed, which just makes me want to order more to get other unique kits in my collection. Shipping was quick and easy and they have a fantastic team working there! Will be ordering again!
Easy to deal with, very fast delivery and a great fit
Couldn't be happier. Love my Wellington shirt, great customer service and quick delivery! Couldn't reccomend anymore!
Many thanks My Mystery Shirt this Huai Thalaeng shirt is a beaut. I appreciate the discount.
This is actually the most underrated Mystery shirt company that I've have come across and i will be buying again
Absolutely quality I can’t fault them and are the best Mystery Shirt company out there, will be ordering again
Definitely worth the money! My first mystery Shirt was right on ! It’s like they new my taste in Shirt ! Can’t wait for my next one
Amazing service, I'm over the moon. I got a Cameroon national shirt and a German league shirt. So happy with them.
Really quick delivery and a high quality football shirt.
Amazing Experience from start to finish. I have a large excluaion list and communication from company was outstanding and they were able to get me strip for collection. 10 out of 10.
Easy buying experience and once never disappoints, great shirt and one I have never heard of before. Thank you again
Got the USA World Cup top and it’s amazing. Thank you so much, will definitely be buying from you guys again
Another great shirt from the guys. Always a pleasure to receive the monthly shirt. Many thanks
We all love these shirts for surprise presents.
Thank you so much for the latest shirt. I really love receiving these each month, especially the more obscure ones! Get loads of positive comments when wearing them!
Outstanding Service I had originally started order but never completed. Company reached to understand my exclusions (over 50) that I had stated and advised they could provide a shirt for me. Great service
This has got to be one of the best mystery shirts I have received to date. Can't wait to walk out in this one!. Many thanks for another brilliant addition to my growing shirt collection
Bought 3 shirts for the family and absolutely loved the whole experience, the anticipation of the surprise made it even more fun! The tops are unique that I wouldn't have thought to pick myself, which makes it all the more exciting. Great customer service, they reached out before delivery and again afterwards to make sure everything was perfect. Thanks so much, team. One very happy customer here!
Bought my first "mystery shirt" and I got this beauty! Extremely happy with the quality. Definitely would recommend ordering with them
Absolutely love my mystery shirt! I wasn’t sure what to expect, but it completely exceeded my expectations. The quality is top-notch — soft material, perfect fit, and the design was such a pleasant surprise. You can tell there’s real care put into picking these out. It’s honestly one of those things that makes you want to order another just to see what you’ll get next. Brilliant value for money and a really fun idea — highly recommend!
Unbelievable service from the team at my mystery shirt, ordered last minute for my sons birthday and without hesitation they made sure it would be here on time and they delivered that promise, the shirt itself is outstanding, unusual and what this gift is all about, can't thank the team enough I have 1 happy birthday boy today, will 100% be using this company again.
Another great month! Another great shirt!. These guys absolutely know how to keep their customers happy. Thanks so much
Asked for an obscure, random team for my Dad, who wouldn’t wear certain teams. Got this class Turkish teams kit, he loved it (even if a little long)
I took a chance on a mystery shirt and wasn’t sure what to expect — but I’m seriously impressed. The packaging was tidy, delivery was quick, and the shirt I received is an absolute gem. It’s not something I would have picked myself, but I genuinely love it.
Absolutely beautiful quality — I was genuinely impressed. The shirt arrived in just 3 days and made for an amazing surprise. Would highly recommend this to any football fan!
Amazing experience. Easy to order. Quick Shipping. Best mystery box company I’ve come across! Definitely recommend everyone gives this a shot.
Another great shirt. This time from the Canadian Premier league.......I didn't know they had one! Brilliant 👏 👏 👏
Still happy with the shirts, even after months.
Great quality, really had a fun time opening it up with the Lads, recommend 100%!
Brilliant played the stick or twist game and landed this beauty really pleased with it
Love this company, prefer the obscure unknown teams and this one from the Mexican 2nd Division is the business 👌🏻
Great quality kits of niche teams! Excellent customer service
My first order and the delivery was fast and good. The quality of the shirt is great.
What a great concept, the shirt is of excellent quality.
I wasn't expecting much, but i actually got a Real Madrid shirt! I really love it and the service was great. This is the best mystery box company there is!
Amazing service, and really quick. Can’t wait to order again and will definitely not use other similar companies moving forward
Top quality products. Faultless customer service. Emailed over a query and they got back to me really quick. 100% would recommend
Absolutely love it. Fits great and a great surprise and my favourite colour as a plus! Safe to say il be subscribing monthly thankyou x